Your VA decision letter decides each claimed issue separately, and one letter can grant one condition, deny another, and defer a third. To use the letter effectively, you need to know what each section contains, which numbers to check on every issue, and when your deadline to request a review runs out.
What the cover letter actually contains
The cover letter, called the Redesigned Automated Decision Letter, is a summary document, not the full decision. VA's internal procedures require it to include three parts: a "Your Benefits Information" section that lists each issue decided and your new combined rating, a "How VA Combines Percentages" section that walks through the math, and a "Review Options" section that explains the three paths available if you disagree.
M21-1, Part VI, Subpart i, Chapter 1, Section B – Decision Notices[1]The combined rating section matters if you have more than one rated condition. VA does not add your percentages together. Instead it applies a whole-person formula: the second rating applies to whatever percentage of you is unaffected by the first condition, and so on. The result is almost always lower than a straight sum. The cover letter shows the specific calculation for your ratings, so check the arithmetic there rather than trying to guess from your individual percentages alone.
The cover letter also arrives with VA Form 20-0998, an enclosure titled "Your Right to Seek Review of Our Decision." That form states the one-year deadline and summarizes your three review options. Keep it. If you request review later, the date on the cover letter is the reference point.
VA Form 20-0998 – Your Right to Seek Review of Our Decision[2]The rating decision: the document behind the cover letter
The rating decision is a separate document from the cover letter, and it is the one that actually explains VA's reasoning. Under VA's adjudication manual, the rating decision must have two parts: a Narrative and a Codesheet. The Narrative contains an Introduction, a Decision section for each issue, an Evidence section listing what VA considered, and a Reasons for Decision section for each issue.
M21-1, Part V, Subpart iv, Chapter 1, Section A – Completing the Rating Decision Narrative[3]The cover letter tells you what VA decided. The rating decision tells you why. If VA denied a condition, the Reasons for Decision section is where you will find the explanation, including which regulations VA applied and which evidence it found insufficient. That section is also where you identify what a future review would need to address.
VA is required to send both under its claimant notification obligations.
38 CFR § 3.103 – Procedural Due Process and Other Rights[4]Do not rely only on what the cover letter says about a denial. Pull out the rating decision and read the Reasons for Decision for each issue before you decide anything about a review.
The three things to check on every issue
For each condition in your decision, there are three elements that can be right or wrong, and each one is something you can dispute in a review.
Service connection. This is whether VA recognized that your condition is linked to your military service. Without service connection, you have no rating and no compensation for that condition. If VA denied service connection, the rating decision will explain the specific reason, whether it was a lack of a current diagnosis, a missing link to service, or a determination that your condition pre-existed service without aggravation.
Rating percentage. If VA granted service connection, it assigned a percentage from 0 to 100 in 10-point increments. The percentage determines how much compensation you receive. The rating decision will reference the diagnostic code VA applied and, in many cases, state what the next higher rating would require. That information tells you what evidence might support a higher rating.
Effective date. The effective date is when VA says your benefit payments begin. Under the general rule, the effective date for an initial claim is the date VA received your claim or the date your entitlement arose, whichever is later.
38 CFR § 3.400 – General Effective Dates[5]An earlier effective date means more back pay. If you believe your claim was filed earlier than VA recorded, or if you think an earlier informal claim or intent to file should control, the effective date is worth examining carefully. It is often the most underestimated element in a decision letter.
VA News – How to File a Notice of Disagreement on Your VA Compensation Claim[6]How VA explains its reasons and what evidence it used
The Reasons for Decision section in the rating decision is where VA is supposed to address all pertinent evidence and all of your contentions. That is a requirement, not a courtesy.
M21-1, Part V, Subpart iv, Chapter 1, Section A – Completing the Rating Decision Narrative[3]Read the Evidence section for each issue and compare it to the records you know exist. If you submitted a private medical opinion, a buddy statement, or a specific treatment record and it does not appear in the Evidence section, that is a gap worth noting. An accredited representative can help you assess whether the omission is a procedural error or whether the record was simply not in VA's possession when the decision was made.
The rating decision is also required to identify favorable findings. These are facts VA accepted in your favor. Favorable findings carry forward automatically in later claims and appeals, meaning VA cannot re-litigate a fact it already conceded in your favor. If your rating decision lists favorable findings, note them and keep a copy of that document.
If VA did not address a contention you raised in your claim, that is not necessarily an oversight you should ignore. Under 38 CFR § 3.103, VA's notice obligations include addressing the issues raised.
38 CFR § 3.103 – Procedural Due Process and Other Rights[4]Whether an unaddressed contention requires correction through a specific review path is a legal judgment an accredited attorney or representative should make after reviewing the full rating decision.
Your one-year deadline and what happens if it passes
For most VA disability compensation decisions, you have one year from the date on the decision letter to request a Supplemental Claim, a Higher-Level Review, or a Board Appeal.
VA.gov – Decision Reviews FAQs[7] VA Form 20-0998 – Your Right to Seek Review of Our Decision[2]The three options work differently:
- A Supplemental Claim requires new and relevant evidence that VA did not have before. It triggers VA's duty to assist in developing the record.
- A Higher-Level Review goes to a senior reviewer who was not involved in the original decision. No new evidence is added. The reviewer can agree or disagree with the original decision based on the existing record, and can call you for an informal conference.
- A Board Appeal goes to a Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans' Appeals. You choose one of three review lanes: direct review (no new evidence), evidence submission, or a hearing.
You can only have one review pending on the same issue at a time. Choosing all three at once does not work.
The one-year window matters for your effective date, not just your ability to appeal. If you file a Supplemental Claim within one year of the decision, VA may treat your claim as continuously pursued from the original filing date, preserving your earlier effective date.
38 CFR § 3.400 – General Effective Dates[5]If you miss the one-year window, a Supplemental Claim is still available. But if VA grants the claim, the effective date will generally be the date of the new Supplemental Claim receipt, not the original claim date. The gap between those two dates is back pay you will not recover.
Higher-Level Review and Board Appeal are generally not available after the one-year period closes. Some benefits types carry shorter deadlines, and the decision letter itself will note those where they apply.
VA.gov – Decision Reviews FAQs[7]How to find accredited help to review your letter
VA accredits three categories of people to help veterans with claims: attorneys, claims agents, and representatives of VA-recognized veterans service organizations (VSOs).
38 CFR § 14.629 – Requirements for Accreditation of Claims Agents or Attorneys[8]You can search the VA Office of General Counsel's accreditation database on VA.gov to verify that any representative you are considering holds current accreditation. The database is searchable by name, organization, and location.
VSO representation is typically free. Attorneys and claims agents may charge fees, and those fees are regulated under federal law. A VA-accredited attorney's fee agreement must comply with 38 USC § 5904 and 38 CFR § 14.636, which set the conditions under which attorneys may charge, what must be in a fee agreement, and what amounts are permissible.
38 USC § 5904 – Recognition of Representatives of Organizations; Requirement for Accreditation[9] 38 CFR § 14.636 – Payment of Fees for Representation[10]Fee structures vary. Some attorneys work on contingency tied to past-due benefits if the claim is successful. Others structure fees differently. The rules require that any fee be reasonable and that the agreement be in writing. Asking about fees before engaging any paid representative is the right move, and an accredited representative is required to explain their fee structure to you.
VA accreditation is what authorizes someone to represent veterans before VA. It is separate from state bar admission. An attorney who is licensed to practice law in your state is not automatically authorized to represent you in VA proceedings without VA accreditation.
38 CFR § 14.629 – Requirements for Accreditation of Claims Agents or Attorneys[8]Common questions
What is the difference between the cover letter and the rating decision?
The cover letter summarizes what was decided and lists your review options. The rating decision is the full document behind it. It explains the evidence VA looked at, VA's reasons for each decision, and the specific rating rules applied. You need both to understand your claim.
What does my effective date mean and why does it matter?
The effective date is when VA says your benefit payments begin. Usually it matches the date VA received your claim. An earlier effective date means more back pay. If you think VA got it wrong, the effective date is something you can dispute in a review.
What can I do if VA denied one of my conditions?
You have three review options: a Supplemental Claim (new evidence), a Higher-Level Review (senior reviewer, same record), or a Board Appeal (a Veterans Law Judge). For most VA benefits you have one year from the decision letter date to pick one. A Supplemental Claim stays available after that window, but your effective date may change.
How does VA calculate my combined rating if I have more than one condition?
VA does not add percentages together. It uses a whole-person formula that reduces the value of each additional rating. The cover letter includes a section called 'How VA Combines Percentages' that shows the math for your specific ratings.
Where can I find accredited help to review my decision letter?
VA accredits attorneys, claims agents, and veterans service organization representatives to help with claims. You can search the VA's Office of General Counsel accreditation database at va.gov to find someone qualified. VSO help is typically free; attorneys and agents may charge fees under VA rules.
A lawyer for every veteran.
Read the mission behind the planned Pete Law firm. Pete Law is seeking Arizona ABS licensure and is not open for clients.
Citations
- M21-1, Part VI, Subpart i, Chapter 1, Section B – Decision Notices (M21-1, Part VI, Subpart i, Ch. 1, § B)
- VA Form 20-0998 – Your Right to Seek Review of Our Decision (VA Form 20-0998)
- M21-1, Part V, Subpart iv, Chapter 1, Section A – Completing the Rating Decision Narrative (M21-1, Part V, Subpart iv, Ch. 1, § A)
- 38 CFR § 3.103 – Procedural Due Process and Other Rights (38 CFR § 3.103)
- 38 CFR § 3.400 – General Effective Dates (38 CFR § 3.400)
- VA News – How to File a Notice of Disagreement on Your VA Compensation Claim (VA News (VA.gov))
- VA.gov – Decision Reviews FAQs (VA.gov Decision Reviews FAQs)
- 38 CFR § 14.629 – Requirements for Accreditation of Claims Agents or Attorneys (38 CFR § 14.629)
- 38 USC § 5904 – Recognition of Representatives of Organizations; Requirement for Accreditation (38 USC § 5904)
- 38 CFR § 14.636 – Payment of Fees for Representation (38 CFR § 14.636)